Free bad presentation examples game
Deck Doctor: find the six mistakes
This deck is sick. It informs, but that’s it: no decision, no action. Find what’s wrong.
The patient: the Customer Support team plans its shifts in a spreadsheet today. They want a shift scheduling tool, and they compared two contenders, Rotaboard and Teamplan. They showed this deck to their director to propose one. Forty minutes later, there was no decision and a follow-up meeting in the diary. Find what went wrong.
Mistakes 0 of 6 · Points 0 of 60
The deck: “Shift scheduling tool for Customer Support: review”
From the course Critical Thinking at Work in the AI Era, by Santiago Tacoronte.
Bad presentation examples, and the fix
Every team has seen this deck: background, context, methodology, a market overview, and on the last slide, "Next steps: let's discuss". Everyone leaves with more information, but there is no decision or action, and the meeting books another meeting.
The deck in the game above is one of those bad presentation examples. Nothing in it is false. The slides are tidy, the prices add up, and somebody did the work to collect 31 survey answers. It still fails because the team built it to report what they found. A deck that needs a decision needs a different shape.
A deck that gets a decision fits on four slides: the decision in one sentence with your answer, the options with doing nothing, the facts that change the choice, and the ask: your recommendation with an owner and a date.
The six mistakes in this bad deck
Here are the six mistakes the game hides, in the order a director would trip over them.
- No decision asked: The last slide says "Next steps: let's discuss". A discussion has no end point, so the meeting ends with another meeting. End on the question you need answered: approve what, by when.
- No recommendation: Slide 10, "Conclusions", says both tools meet the team's needs. The team did the work and knows which tool it wants. Keep that to yourself and the room has to guess.
- The key facts are hidden: Two of three sites have unreliable internet, and Rotaboard only works online. Facts like these change the choice, and they sit on slide 8 in small print, after seven slides of background.
- Irrelevant information: Slide 5 shows a market overview of twelve tools for a choice between two. It takes up the room's time and moves nobody closer to a decision.
- No owner and no date: Nobody in the deck owns the decision, and nothing says when the director has to decide. Without both, it drifts to next month.
- A missing option: The team uses a spreadsheet today. Keeping it costs €0, and it belongs on the list. Doing nothing shows what each tool really adds, and sometimes it wins.
These are powerpoint mistakes of structure, and a beautiful deck can make all six. Bad presentation examples rarely look bad.
What goes on the ask slide
If you ask me, the whole deck is just an excuse for the ask slide. What goes on it? Four things.
First, what you actually think they should do. One line. For example: Teamplan.
Then, why. The facts that tip it. Like: it costs €1,440 more a year, but it works at all three sites.
Who owns it? One name or one role. Owner: the support lead.
And when you need the decision. A day. Decision by Friday.
If you can't write that slide, you're not ready for the meeting. Go back to your notes and find the facts that change the choice.
The decision deck: four slides
Here's the cure for these bad presentation examples: the same decision as a decision deck.
- The decision: "Approve a scheduling tool for the support team by Friday. Our answer: Teamplan."
- The options: Rotaboard (€5,760 a year, online only) · Teamplan (€7,200 a year, works offline) · keep the spreadsheet (€0).
- The facts: two of the three sites have unreliable internet, and only Teamplan works offline. Both tools have a mobile app. Teamplan costs €1,440 more a year.
- The ask: Approve Teamplan. It costs €1,440 more a year, and it works at all three sites. Owner: the support lead. Decision by Friday.
The cheaper tool lost, but the facts that decided it were sitting on slide 8 the whole time. Everything else from the eleven-slide version (background, context, methodology, risks) can sit in the appendix for anyone who actually wants it, and the market overview of twelve tools goes in the bin.
AI decks make it worse
Ask an AI for a deck and you'll get a long deck of polished slides that all look the same, like the eleven above. Researchers at Stanford's Social Media Lab and BetterUp Labs called this workslop in 2025: AI-generated content that looks good but has nothing under the hood.
The AI can format slides, but it can't know that slide 8 is the one that matters. That's your job. Write the decision sentence and your answer yourself first, pick the facts that change the choice, then let the AI do the formatting.
How to play Deck Doctor
Bad presentation examples stick better when you find the mistakes yourself.
- Read the deck. Each card is one slide.
- Tap a slide and say what's wrong with its message, or just say "Looks fine".
- Decide if you'd keep it, move it to the appendix, or delete it.
- Any time, drag the slides left in your deck into the right order.
- Two mistakes aren't on any slide. Find them with "Something's missing".
The counter shows the mistakes you've found and your points. If you get stuck, a hint pops up after a few wrong picks. At the end, you'll see the deck you built next to the four-slide version that fixes everything. Back to the deck
Questions about decision decks
What is a decision deck?
A short presentation built to get one decision: the decision and your answer, the options with doing nothing, the facts that change the choice, and the ask: your recommendation with an owner and a date.
How many slides should a decision deck have?
Four is usually enough. Everything else goes in the appendix, or in the bin.
What goes on the ask slide?
What you think they should do, why, who owns it, and when you need the decision.
Why include doing nothing as an option?
It shows what each option actually adds, and sometimes it wins.
What are the usual bad presentation examples at work?
A deck that ends on "let's discuss", a conclusions slide with no recommendation, the key facts buried in the middle, and pages of analysis that change nothing. The game above has all of them.
Is the deck in the game a real case?
No. I made up the company, the team and both tools for my course Critical Thinking at Work in the AI Era.
Not sure how much care a decision needs? Try the one-way and two-way doors game.
What does a slow decision cost your team? Try the Decision Cost Calculator.
Built by Santiago Tacoronte, with 20 years of data and analytics leadership experience at Virgin, flydubai, Philip Morris, and Mondelez. More free tools in the resources library.